With this piece of evidence, the Defence concluded their Cross-Examination and there was no ReExamination.
PW4, Mrs. Mobolanle Folaranmi, the Public Servant and Assistant Director with the Claims Resolution
Department of the Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (herein after referred to as NDIC) also
tendered in this regard,the Statement of Account of Ebenezer Retnan Ventures, which was admitted
as Exhibit P15C.
PW5, Cyril Tsenyil, the Accountant General of Plateau State testified under Oath that from the Year
2000 he was the Personal Assistant to the Speaker of the House of Assembly of Plateau State. He was
invited by the EFCC on the 2nd of June 2015 through a Letter, which contained a List of Account
Numbers evidencing transactions dating back to the Year 2000, and was asked to bring the
Documents together with the Cheques evidencing certain transactions, the Payment Vouchers and the
Bank Statements. He engaged his Staff to search for the Requested Documents, which could not be
found and he wrote to Diamond Bank to avail him with the Statements of those Transactions. Before
he got possession of the Documents from the Bank, he reported the progress of his search to the EFCC
who asked him to produce some Staff who where present during the reported Transactions, and one
of them was Mr. Paul Datugun, General Manager, Direct Labour Agency. They were not able to trace
any Voucher relating to the Cheques from their Records.
He explained that the role of the Accountant General is to ensure that the Defined Channels through
which Payment Vouchers are generated, follow Due Process, in that there must be an Approval by the
Executive Governor or an Accounting Officer of a Ministry, Department and Agency, whose Approval
is sent to the Director of Treasury to Process the Approval for Payment. The Director of Treasury then
sends it onwards to the Account (Other Charges) or Account (Salaries) depending on the case, to raise
the Payment Voucher. After the Auditor checks this Payment Voucher, it is passed back to the
Accountant General, to check whether the Payment Voucher together with the Attachments such as
the Initial Approval, etc., satisfied the requirements, whereupon he authorizes Payment either
through the Medium of a Cheque or by e-Payment Instructions. He added that the Accountant General
would not pay out Government Monies without the Vouchers.
He was questioned as to the basis in which a Governor of a State can lend his State Money or assist his
State in buying things, and his response was that he did not know of any basis, or of any modality for
lending the State Money. A Governor approves Payment of all the State’s Expenditures.
Mr. Cyril stated that the modalities for borrowing State any Money are firstly that the Ministry, or
Agency or Department needing to borrow Money will first of all raise a Memo to the Executive
Governor of the State intimating him of the need to borrow a certain amount, and once Approval is
obtained from the Governor, that Ministry will go on to the next level by approaching either a
Financial Institution or Bank, seeking such Loan. The Lending Institution would need to see the
Executive Council’s (EXCO) Resolution and also that of the House of Assembly’s Resolution in a
Democratic Setting. He added that the Repayment of this Sum borrowed, would not be to a Third
Party or Stranger to the Loan but to the Creditor directly. He stated further that since he assumed
Office as the Accountant General of Plateau State, he had never heard of Ebenezer Retnan Ventures
lending the Plateau State Government, any Money.
Under Cross-Examination by the Defence, he stated that the first time he came across the List of
Cheques was when they were shown to him by the EFCC and at the time the Transactions took place,
he was not the Accountant General of Plateau State. Therefore, he would not know whether the
conditions for their Payments were met or not and whether the then Accountant General was
160