court and what the witness said is not the truth. The axe and cutlass which PW1 said were used, are owned by him. M.L. Maidoki Esq: That is all for this witness. Court: Cross examination. M.B. Abubakar Esq: Do you know late Abubakar Umaru? DW2: Yes I know him but I don’t know where he is because I have been in detention for about 3 years now. I can remember our last meeting with him was when he lodged a complaint against our father about 3 years ago. I fight ensured between the children of our elder brother and our sister and I came to know because our elder brother lodged a complaint before our Village Head and when the Village Head inform our elder brother to relocate to another house for peace to reign, he refused and called our father a pigeon and attempted to cut our father and I protected our father as a result he cut me on the head and I retaliated and we all fell down and both of us were taken to hospital, but I don’t know what happened to him later. I forgot whether I made a statement at CID because I was sick at that time. I can’t remember making a statement at CID because I was sick as I have said. It is not true that our elder brother died because of my retaliation as it was only God who knows. M.B. Abubakar Esq: That is all for this witness. Kamal O. Fagbemi Esq: No any cross-examination. Court: Re-examination. M.L. Maidoki Esq: No any re-examination. Court: The witness is hereby discharged. DW3 (after affirmation): My name is Abubakar Bashir Ummaru. I live at Kibiyare. I know why I am in court because it was alleged Page 25 of 29

Select target paragraph3