bring food to me at my shop. After he brought the food, he told me that he wanted to go to kwanberu to collect a message and I said is OK. After he left, I heard him shouting before he reached the place calling my name “Jafar, Jafar come”. I then rushed to where he was and found him in pool of blood and I asked him “who did this to you? And he said it was Bilal and other 3 person”. Thereafter Ahmad’s uncle arrived in person of Usman Mustapha (PW1) and asked what is happening. After I told him what happened, he asked me to call Ahmad’s parents. Then called them and when they came we took him to specialist hospital, Sokoto. Then they refer us to Usman Danfodiyo University Teaching Hospital, Sokoto. He was admitted and we were there up to 2/4/2020 when Ahmad died. H.S. Buhari Esq: That is all for the witness. Court: CROSS EXAMINATION S. Ovia Esq: You said you are a businessman, where is your shop located? PW2: Yes and my shop is located at Garge area, Sokoto and the place where I met Ahmad is not far away from my shop. S. Ovia Esq: What time did you hear the deceases screamed? Page 10 of 22

Select target paragraph3