(/
I
l i
,l /·
19
{/
,'
I
nd
told him to mention his name. However, the 2 defendant whom
he claimed told him to implicate lzuchukwu Okeke in his statement
which is Exhibit "D" denied committing the offence and did not
nd
mention the name of lzuchukwu Okeke. It was in his alleged 2
1
statement which is Exhibit "D " that he admitted robbing the P.W .1
with the 1st defendant and also exonerated lzuchukwu Okeke. It is
1
1
therefore, discernible that Exhibits "C" , "C " and "D " and the
circumstantial evidence from the P.W.1, P.W .2 and P.W .3 that one
of the robbers was inflicted with several machete cuts on his head
during the robbery operation and the 1 st defendant was arrested
with fresh machete cuts wound on his head in the morning of the
incident are the evidence tendered by the prosecution in proof of
the offence of commission of robbery against the defendants. The
question that · is relevant to ask at this point is whether the
defendants (and especially the 2 nd defendant) can be convicted on
the basis of their confessional statements which are Exhibits "C",
"C 1" and "D 1" in view of the fact that they retracted their extra
judicial statements in their testimonies in Court? The law is now
firmly established as rightly submitted by the learned counsel for
the prosecution that where a defendant confesses to a crime in his
extra judicial statement to the pol ice but in court, he retracts from
his confession , prudence and the well laid down practice is that
before such a : defendant is convicted on the said confessional
statement, the Court looks for some evidence outside the
confession which would make the confession probable.
SEE : OMOJU VS . F. R. N. (2008) 7 NWRL (PT. 1085)
38.
STEPHEN VS . STATE (2013) 8 NWLR (PT. 1355)
153.
In other words , before giving legal effect to a confessional
state~~nt ~f a defendant, I am enjoined to test it as to its truth by
examining It along with other evidence to determine whether it is
probable. In order to be able to do this , the appellate courts have
set some guiding principles and I am implored to ask myself the
following questions:(a) ls there anything outside the confession to show that it is true?
(b) Is it corroborated?
cou~f--- ·or _,.·:~ ..
H1G~
i 7 AUG 2017