was waiting for a Letter of Award of the Contract. These Set of Facts in this Letter, appear not to show
any relationship or connection or relevance to the Documents leading up to the Award of Contract
dated the 5th of June 2001.
This Exhibit D25, as presented by the Defence, had neither a Head nor Tail. It appears to be a
Stranger among the Lot presented before the Court. It is more like a Single White Sheep amongst a
Herd of Black Sheep. This Exhibit appears lost, and perhaps wonders what it is doing under the gaze
of the Court. It’s Purpose, could only mean that the Secretary to the State Government was in another
Contract with Pinnacle Communications Limited regarding the Purchase, Supply, Installation and
Commissioning of Equipment for the benefit of the PRTV and definitely, not for the Upgrading of
PRTV’s Television and AM and FM Radio Stations.
The set of circumstances that remain constant throughout the Documentary Exhibits is the fact that
the Communications were strictly between the General Manager of PRTV and the Executive Governor,
Chief Joshua Chibi Dariye, the Defendant. During Trial, the Defendant chose to keep himself away from
the Witness Box, Mr. Lucky Omoluwa the Chairman/Chief Executive of Pinnacle Communications or
its Representative were not called or summoned to testify, either by the Defence or most importantly
by the Prosecution, and further, the General Manager of the PRTV, Mr. Joseph Ari was also not called
or summoned by the Defence.
Starting off with the General Manager of the PRTV, his evidence was crucial as his name featured
throughout the Exhibits, which establishes a Trail of Communications between himself and the
Defendant. He also would have explained in great detail the involvement of the State Tenders Board in
the Award of the Contract, as well as explained the Process that led to the whittling down of the
Quotation initially presented by Pinnacle Communications Limited, in its Executive Report and
Quotation. Most importantly, he is presumed to have knowledge on the Source of Funds for the
Contract, as the Purchase of the Upgrading of the PRTV Television and Radio Station as well as the
Request of Payment ended up on his desk.
DW12, Mr. Israel Dabel, the Director of Engineering of the PRTV, during his testimony, stated that he
was not aware of the Funds Allocated for the Purchase of the Upgrading of the PRTV Station, he also
was not aware of the Amount paid by the Plateau State Government or knew the Procedure of
Payment to the Contractor, and he finally, did not know any Financial Aspects of the PRTV Contract.
The Court observes from his testimony that it does not tally with the Documentary Exhibits
considered by the Court, when he stated that a “Team” and mentioned the names of the Team
Members that visited the Harris’ Factory in the United Kingdom. Meanwhile, the Visit for Inspection
and Training at Harris Factory, only involved himself, as Director of Engineering and Mr. Joseph Ari,
the General Manager.The fact that they visited Harris UK was fully captured in the Approved Estacode
Allowances contained in Exhibits D27, written by the Secretary to the State Government, Mr. Ezekiel
Gomos, on the 8th of August 2001.
The Court further notes that the Estacode was paid by the Plateau State Government and not by
Pinnacle Communications Limited, the Contractor, who had earlier in the Executive Report and
Quotation stated that the Contractor would be responsible for this Visit, Inspection and Training of
Two Officials at Harris Factory in the United Kingdom.
150