who mentioned the names I mentioned when he was arrested. The 1st Defendant was arrested at Kabawa Village in the night when the incident happened. That is all. Abbas Samaila Esq: That is all for this witness. Court: CROSS-EXAMINATION M.I. Hanafi Esq: you were at the scene of the incident, you would have helped to stop the fight, you being a representative of the village head? PW3: Yes and I couldn’t stop the boys from beating Ausa Umar because I was not at the scene of crime. M.I. Hanafi Esq: All the names you mentioned, you mentioned then because you heard the 1st Defendant mentioning their names? PW3: Yes. M.I. Hanafi Esq: If you’re at the scene of the crime, you would have prevented Abdullahi Dikko from being killed? PW3: Yes of course, I cannot leave them to kill him. M.I. Hanafi Esq: It was because you were not there they killed Abdullahi Dikko? PW3: If I was there I cannot prevent him from being killed because he was predestined to die and the only thing I did was to call the police. M.I. Hanafi Esq: Who actually beat you and your brother Abdullahi Dikko? PW3: I cannot say because I was not there. M.I. Hanafi Esq: That is all for the witness. Court: Re-Examination. Page 12 of 24

Select target paragraph3