r
!
f
<'// .
10
; l
,
the defendants as Exhibits "C" , "C 1" , "O" and "0 111 . The learned
counsel for the prosecution in his final written address submitted
that the statements are confessional statements of the defendants
and so supported their case that the offence was armed robbery.
The defendants in their evidence before the Court challenged
Exhibits "C" , "C 1" , "O" and "0 1" on the ground that they were not
obtained voluntc;lrily. In another breath the 1st defendant clairped
that he did not sign any document at the office of the SARS.
Having admitted the statements of the defendants as exhibits, they
become part of the case for the prosecution and I am therefore
bound to consider their probative value notwithstanding the
retraction by the defendants in their testimony before the Court.
What is important is the weight I will attach to such confession and
retraction during my fact finding mission as such a retraction does
not necessarily make the confession inadmissible.
SEE : NWACHUKWU VS . THE STATE (2007) 17 NWLR
(PT. 1062) 31 .
EGBOGHONOME VS . THE
NWLR (PT. 306) 383 .
WJ
u
►·
~
...
-'(
--...
.x:
ft]
I
,-....
• z
'ii
STATE
(1993)
7
When is a statement confessional? By the provisions of section 28
of the Evidence ·Act, 2011 "a confession is an admission made at
any time by a person charged with a crime, stating or suggesting
the inference that he committed that crime ." For a statement to
constitute a confession , the maker must admit or acknowledge that
he committed the offence for which he is arrested . The admission
must be clear, precise and unequivocal. In other words, a
confessional statement will be relevant if it establishes beyond
reasonable doubt the ingredients of the offence for which the
defendant is charged as well as the identity of the defendant.
Again , before th.ere can be said to have been an armed robbery,
the defendant or defendants must have stolen something which is
capable of being stolen with violence or being armed with
dangerous weapon . Any person who is in company of a person
armed while robbery is being committed is also guilty of
11
commission of armed robbery. Are Exhibits "C", "C 1", "0 and "0 1"
really confessional statements? It is therefore pertinent at this
juncture to reproduce the relevant portions of Exhibits "C", "C 1" ,
"O" and "0 1" in order to ascertain if they are confessional
statement. The relevant portion of Exhibit "C" reads:-